Thomas Straker has arrived in New York City. After opening his namesake Notting Hill restaurant in 2022 and quickly becoming a fixture on London’s culinary scene, the chef and “All Things Butter” creator found a new home on Grand Street and West Broadway in Soho this October.
The address formerly belonged to Lucky Strike, Keith McNally’s neighborhood haunt known for its who’s-who list of regulars from Madonna to Sir Paul McCartney, who hosted his 50th birthday party in the back room. The beloved bistro shuttered in 2020 after 31 years, leaving an outsized imprint on the city’s collective memory. Straker tapped Brooklyn-based design studio Post Company, the team behind Raf’s and INNESS, to transform the space into Straker’s NYC.
Post Company founding partner Leigh Salem tells Surface what accepting the project signified. “We’re standing on the shoulders of giants. You can’t underestimate how powerful that is,” he says. Though McNally’s legacy looms, chef Straker’s name carries its own cachet. A custom “Lucky Straker’s” ceramic vase perched atop the bar is as much an homage as an assertion of his place in the downtown lineage. “We nod in both directions, to Lucky Strike and to our London origins,” Straker says. “We’re not changing our style.”
Photo by Thomas Streat, courtesy of Straker’s…
Straker’s NYC shares its sibling’s material DNA, with wood wainscoting and a deep green honed marble bar top. Straker proposed a third grounding element for the Soho restaurant: an oversized zinc hood that references the neighborhood’s historic cast-iron language. “Bringing that much metal into a very small space made us nervous,” Salem recalls. To protect the room’s patina, fabricators softened the zinc’s finish through a six-step mottling process and juxtaposed it with high-gloss white ceiling paint that reveals the original beadboard’s imperfections.
Beneath the metal hood, the theater of the kitchen unfolds in full view. Straker isn’t one to shy away from exposure, with five million social media followers watching his backyard cooking tutorials and exotic sourcing excursions, so knocking down the walls to open the space was a given. “You walk in and get straight into the experience. The fire is on, the barbecue is roaring. It’s exciting,” he says.
Photo by Thomas Streat, courtesy of Straker’s…
The restaurant offers no shortage of spectacle—art advisory Beaumont Nathan procured six large-scale Damien Hirst sketches and bold Keith Haring prints of Elvis Presley and Marilyn Monroe—but Straker and head chef Luka Coyne’s delicate choreography draws the most attention. As one spoons apricot hot sauce over a plate of grilled lamb skewers and the other slides past to coax a mussel flatbread slicked with chilli butter into the wood-fired oven, guests linger to observe the action.
Straker admits that the curiosity is mutual. “It’s nice to be able to talk to people at the counter,” he says. “For the first five years of my career, I never saw the dining room. Here, the cooks aren’t squirrelled away in the basement, and they get to feel the energy and see the food get delivered.”
The New York menu leans on locally sourced fish and meat, seasonal produce, and Straker’s signature infused butters to riff on Notting Hill’s favorite dishes. Gone are the European sea bass and John Dory; instead, you’ll find expertly prepared Jonah crab, striped bass, and Montauk tuna on offer.
Photo by Thomas Streat, courtesy of Straker’s…
The most significant difference from London, Straker explains, is the presence of the back dining room. Polished yet unfussy, the space evokes an intimate dinner party. His mandate was simple: “sexy, elegant, and nice music.” A single banquette upholstered in chocolate corduroy wraps around the room, while Italodisco, German funk, and ‘90s rap boom from wood-paneled speakers. “There are so many big, showy restaurants nowadays,” Salem says. “This is a return to something cozy, where it feels special to be there.”
With a wait list rumored to top 45,000 people, Straker’s NYC has cemented itself as the city’s new status reservation. If you can get in, steal a glance at the prized corner booth—you might spot McNally holding court.