Courtesy of NoHo Hospitality Group and The Astor. …
Built between 1850 and 1881, the Lafayette Street landmark began as the Astor Library, one of New York’s earliest major public libraries, which later became part of the New York Public Library before the system moved its main branch to Bryant Park in 1911. In the decades that followed, the building passed through other hands, including the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society after World War II, before falling into disuse and facing demolition in the 1960s. Producer Joseph Papp saved it, and after its designation as a city landmark in 1965, it reopened as The Public Theater, debuting with Hair in 1967.
Years later, when Swiss designer Serge Becker was appointed to reimagine the restaurant of The Public Theater, he knew he wanted the space to speak to its true history; nothing could be fabricated. The result is The Astor, a tavern from NoHo Hospitality Group that brings dining, cocktails, and performance together under one roof. Located in the area that previously housed the theater’s restaurant, The Astor is filled with objects that each have a story tied to the building itself. “We re-envisioned this place, but it actually is based on real history,” says Becker.
The Astor builds on a creative partnership between NoHo Hospitality and The Public Theater that spans nearly three decades, beginning with the opening of Joe’s Pub in 1998. Joe’s Pub had long defined the theater’s nightlife, but the surrounding spaces felt stark and institutional by comparison. “We needed the rest of the public spaces and the restaurant space to speak the same language that Joe’s did,” says general manager Kevin Abbott.
Courtesy of NoHo Hospitality Group and The Astor. …
Abbott and his team searched the building’s corners and uncovered boxes of artifacts, a trove of long-overlooked treasures. Becker then chose the pieces that carried the most meaning and arranged them into a cohesive whole. Among the most memorable finds were a telegram from Jackie Kennedy and the original score of Bring in ‘da Noise, Bring in ‘da Funk, which now rests on the bar’s piano. “It’s not a copy, it’s not a replica,” Abbott says. Becker housed the pieces in imperfect vintage frames, aiming for a space that feels lived-in and real. “It can’t be perfect, it shouldn’t be perfect,” he says. “It’s the mosaic that really matters.” Even the coasters beneath the decanters are artifacts from the building’s history.
The ultimate wow factor, however, is a commissioned mural by Portugal-based artist André Carrilho, roughly three feet tall and 46 feet long, which wraps around three sides of the restaurant at eye level. To tie it closely to The Public Theater’s history, artistic director Oskar Eustis suggested focusing on writers and playwrights, reflecting the theater’s commitment to original American work. The mural features 32 figures, including Lin-Manuel Miranda, David Byrne, and Tony Kushner. Carrilho researched each subject before starting and wove in details drawn from their work: Ruben Santiago-Hudson holds a harmonica, a nod to Lackawanna Blues; Lisa Kron holds a house from Fun Home; and Alicia Keys sits at a piano atop the theater, a reference to her first-ever show, which took place at Joe’s Pub. “It really makes sense to have something that actually tells a cohesive story of this and the important characters of the institution, all in one place, in one style,” Becker says.
Courtesy of NoHo Hospitality Group and The Astor. …
When it came to designing the menu, chef Andrew Carmellini took an elevated American tavern approach, drawing on his “melting pot” view of American cooking. Popular dishes include Pigs in Wellington, an upgraded take on pigs in a blanket served with bourbon mustard; chips with guacamole and ranch; and a rich curry salmon. “We wanted the food to feel elevated but not fussy,” says Abbott. Bar director Darryl Chan’s cocktail program draws on New York’s drinking history with contemporary spirits. The Fancy Bijou pairs green Chartreuse with green maraschino cherries, while the Concord Cobbler combines Lambrusco, fresh grapes, and a fig leaf garnish.
“We are another performance venue within this institution, so there is a showiness that we really wanted to capture,” says Abbott. “I’m watching people every single night exploring the space in a way I’ve never seen in a restaurant, for sure. You see theater enthusiasts who are geeking out because it’s Meryl Streep’s pipe from Mother Courage. Even if you’re not a theater geek, you’re getting an experience that feels like this cool New York moment.”
Courtesy of NoHo Hospitality Group and The Astor. …