Travel Awards

The Candidates for The Best Cruise Ship of 2019 Share DNA, But Aim for Different Targets

Celebrity has produced two entries into the market—the Edge and the Flora—either of which could be the best cruise ship of the year.

Photo courtesy Celebrity

Of all the categories in the annual Surface Travel Awards, the one for Best Cruise Ship or Yacht can be the trickiest. Ocean liners haven’t been on the cutting edge of design since the midcentury when Gio Ponti and other masters lended their tasteful eye to the industry. (One of his commissions, Andrea Doria, would go on to sink though that is a story for another time.)

This year is different. Two strong candidates emerged from an unlikely place: mega-liner brand Celebrity Cruises. Flora resembles a sleek, sustainability-minded boutique hotel, whereas the brand’s wild, vibrant Edge is something like a resort dreamed up by a team of talented designers whose work you wouldn’t typically expect to encounter at sea. Here’s a look at the sister ships.


Celebrity Flora

Smaller in draft than many of its compatriots, Flora offers accommodations for a mere 100 guests (even “small” cruise ships can carry as many as 700 guests these days). On offer are staterooms that would be generous on land, personal suite attendants, and private verandas. Ecuadorian-inspired fare at the main dining room is Michelin worthy, the fittings are luxury, the spaces are organic and elegant, and the overall vibe is relaxed, but smart, thanks to work by BG Studio International, Francesca Bucci, and Adriana Hoyos.

And there’s vision here: Designed specifically for tours of the Galapagos, Flora is energy efficient, stocked with eco-conscious and research-minded innovations, and covered in motifs relating to those islands interlaced with themes of discovery, both personal and scientific. Her architecture and layout stay in line with this; cabins and shared spaces point out, not in, with large windows being a constant. She stands in square opposition to the ongoing cruise trend that seeks to pull the guest into the ship—as if it were a casino—rather than expose them to the ocean.

Overall, it represents an interesting bridge between cruise ship and private yacht with a strong use of site specific themes.

Celebrity Flora 8
Travel Awards
Celebrity Flora
Photo courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Flora

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Flora

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Flora

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Flora

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Flora

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Flora

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Flora

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Flora

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Flora/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Edge

With her interior plazas, theater, massive restaurants, extensive spa, large top-deck pool, and capacity for almost three times as many guests, Edge makes Flora look downright dainty. Yet the same care has been applied here and the same drive towards a general theme: this time, it’s tech.

A dedicated app guides guests through the multistory plaza, over to the state-of-the-art theater that seems primed for a TED Talk, and on to the striking cantilevered deck, and rooftop plaza that seems more a Coachella-era product of experiential design philosophies than a typical lido. All of this, as it turns out, was designed in 3D imaging first and directed by a supergroup of creatives including Tom Wright, Scott Butler, Kelly Hoppen, Patricia Urquiola, Jouin Manku, and more. All those voices, though, haven’t led to confusion; all the of-the-moment, LED-tipped spaces are in harmony with each other, from the Advanced Med Spa, to the six themed dining rooms, to the many surprising, hidden goodies around the ship (the barber shop is a favorite in our offices).

Everything here, from the material choices to the scale and ambition, is gargantuan, yet still welcoming. She’s as if Dubai packed a steamer trunk and took to gallivanting around the Mediterranean.

Celebrity Edge 10
Travel Awards
Celebrity Edge
Image courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Edge

Celebrity Edge

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Edge

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Edge

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Edge

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Edge

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Edge

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Edge

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebritye

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Edge

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity
Celebrity Edge

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

Celebrity Edge/Photo Courtesy Celebrity

See the full list of Surface Travel Awards finalists here.

All Stories