FASHION

Spoiler Alert: Mansur Gavriel’s Men’s Collection Is the Same as Its Women’s Collection

What does it say that the "new" men's collection isn’t so new at all.

Today Mansur Gavriel has shared some “big news.” The minimalist brand best known for its leather goods announced its first men’s accessories collection and ready-to-wear line, that latter of which will launch at the September see-now buy-now show. This all sounds really exciting. But after seeing the collection, this actually isn’t a huge deal.

Here’s why: Essentially, Mansur Gavriel took a uniform line marketed to women, changed a few details, and repackaged it as a separate collection made for men. The label didn’t even need to reverse-engineer the classic “pink it and shrink it” tactic, since, well, the stuff is more or less the same-same anyway. Sticking so rigidly to its templated design language, the brand relied on the premise of something new to keep itself relevant, rather than actually delivering on it. As fans of the brand, we were hoping that an announcement like this would mean we had something novel to covet.

But what really gets my goat is how they’ve been marketed. What does it say that these styles—which share so much with their “feminine” progenitors—use the most basic gendered stereotypes to signal to men that these items are for them. Take, for example, the “Technical” backpack, which is the one we all know with the addition of a pocket, or the fact that a briefcase shows up now that the boys can have something of their own. This dog whistle of masculinity feels cheap and tone deaf.

To demonstrate how little the line has evolved with the addition of these items for men, here’s a side-by-side look at old versus ostensibly new.  

WOMEN’S BACKPACK VS. MEN’S TECHNICAL BACKPACK

The brand’s mainstay backpack got an update with a nice front pocket. The irony is… it’s the perfect place for tampons.

RELATED LIST MEMBERS
Fashion

WOMEN’S BACKPACK VS. MEN’S BACKPACK

Déjà vu?

WOMEN’S CROSS BODY BAG  VS. MEN’S DOPP KIT

Women’s Cross Body Bag – strap + handle = Dopp Kit. Can you even call it a men’s collection without one?

WOMEN’S CARD CASE VS. MEN’S CARD CASE

Do-over.

MEN’S LARGE AND SMALL BRIEFCASES

To be fair, my dad does carry a briefcase. And so does my mom.

WOMEN’S CONTINENTAL WALLET VS. MEN’S ZIP-AROUND WALLET

Finally, a men’s wallet with a coin pouch that can hold the extra 20 cents they make on the dollar.

WOMEN’S TRAVEL BAG VS. MEN’S TRAVEL BAG

Same same.

WOMEN’S LARGE WALLET VS. MEN’S OVERSIZED ATTACHÉ

If a man’s phone-keys-wallet are the same size as mine, why does he get the extra inch? The only logical answer is that size really does matter.

All Stories